ICE propaganda is shaping the national conversation right now, and it is doing so dishonestly. The moral outrage dominating social media and mainstream commentary has nothing to do with immigration enforcement itself. It exists because Donald Trump is enforcing the law. When the same actions happened under Barack Obama, often at a much larger scale, the outrage simply did not exist.
I am not speculating about motives. I am looking at numbers, patterns, and public reaction. When those three are placed side by side, the conclusion becomes unavoidable.
Featured Snippet Takeaway:
ICE propaganda refers to selective moral outrage over immigration enforcement that appears only when one political figure enforces the law, despite similar or greater enforcement under previous administrations being widely ignored.
Immigration law did not change when Trump took office. ICE did not suddenly become a new agency. Deportation authority did not expand. What changed was the political identity of the president. That change alone triggered a wave of moral panic that had been absent for years.
What Actually Happened Under Obama
During the Obama presidency from 2009 to 2017, the United States deported approximately 2.4 million people. That figure remains the highest total of any modern administration. It was not hidden. It was reported at the time. Obama was even referred to by immigration activists as the deporter in chief.
ICE also operated detention facilities throughout those years. Government and advocacy data indicate that approximately 56 people died while in ICE custody during the Obama administration. Those deaths occurred across multiple facilities and years. They were not a secret. They were documented.
Yet there was no sustained national outrage. There were no viral campaigns accusing the administration of cruelty. There was no daily drumbeat of moral condemnation from celebrities, activists, or media personalities. Social media was largely quiet.
This silence matters.
What Is Happening Under Trump
Under the Trump administration, total deportations have been significantly lower than under Obama, even when accounting for both of Trump’s terms combined. Despite a tougher tone and more visible enforcement posture, the raw numbers do not exceed Obama era levels.
Deaths in ICE custody under Trump total approximately 30 so far. That number includes a recent spike concentrated in a single year, but it remains far lower than the cumulative total under Obama.
The enforcement mechanisms are the same. The legal authority is the same. The agency is the same. The outcomes, measured strictly by numbers, are not more severe.
And yet the reaction could not be more different.
The Only Variable That Changed
The only meaningful variable between these two eras is the president enforcing the law.
When Obama enforced immigration law at a massive scale, it was framed as pragmatic governance. When Trump enforces the same law at a smaller scale, it is framed as cruelty.
That is not a moral awakening. It is a political reaction.
Selective outrage is not compassion. It is narrative management. It reveals that the issue is not deportation, detention, or enforcement, but who is doing it.
This is why the current rhetoric feels manufactured. It is why the language escalates so quickly. It is why facts are ignored while emotion is amplified.
A Christian Perspective on Law and Truth
From a Christian worldview, this dishonesty matters far more than party affiliation.
Scripture condemns unequal standards. It condemns false witness. It condemns emotional manipulation disguised as righteousness. Truth is not optional simply because a cause feels urgent.
Scripture also affirms the role of law and governing authority. A nation without enforced laws does not become compassionate. It becomes unstable. Immigration law exists whether people like it or not. Enforcing it is not unbiblical. Pretending it only matters when one man enforces it is.
Christians should be deeply concerned when truth is sacrificed for political theater. Compassion divorced from honesty is not compassion at all.
Why This Matters Now
The propaganda surrounding ICE is not just misleading. It trains people to respond emotionally rather than truthfully. It erodes trust in institutions. It teaches that morality depends on political alignment rather than consistent principles.
When facts are ignored and outrage is selective, society loses its ability to reason. That loss affects everything, including faith, justice, and public order.
Calling this out is not partisan. It is necessary.
The problem is not enforcement. The problem is hypocrisy.
Arch Kennedy
Bold, Unfiltered, and Unafraid
Watch my full commentary below:
What the Satanic Plaque Reveals About Tim Walz
Leave a Reply