I have been watching this heartbreaking story unfold, and the very first sentence of this blog must include Erika Kirk because what happened this week matters deeply to the Church. When a grieving Christian widow has to go on national television to correct rumors that never should have existed in the first place, something is clearly wrong in the world of Christian commentary. I felt compelled to speak because what I am seeing is not only a cultural problem, it is a spiritual one.

Christians must take seriously the moment Erika Kirk publicly pleaded for truth, because her grief exposes the spiritual danger of careless speculation among Christian influencers.

The Moment That Changed Everything

I never wanted to write about this situation. I was already following the controversy because I am a Christian conservative. I have respected many of the people involved at different points in my life. But when I saw Erika sit in that interview, voice trembling, asking the world to stop spreading lies about her husband and her family, I knew this was no longer just an online feud. This was a widow asking for mercy. This was a sister in Christ begging the Body to stop hurting her. When I heard her say these things on Fox News during her recent interview, I felt a heaviness I could not ignore, and you can watch that moment in the Fox News report if you have not already seen it.

As a Christian, I cannot ignore that moment. Scripture commands us to mourn with those who mourn. Scripture commands us to protect the vulnerable. Scripture warns us against gossip, slander, and careless accusations. Everything about this situation touches biblical territory in a way that should make every believer pause. It certainly made me pause.

The Fruit I Cannot Ignore

I used to enjoy listening to Candace Owens. I admired her boldness, her intelligence, and how fearlessly she spoke in a culture that punishes truth-telling. But over the past few weeks, something has felt off in my spirit. I am not judging her soul. Only God knows the heart. Yet Jesus clearly tells us we are allowed to evaluate the fruit, and we see this in Matthew 7:15–20, which warns believers to discern truth by observing a person’s life and actions.

Candace has said publicly that she is a Christian. She has spoken openly about her conversion to Catholicism. I am not here to deny that. I am not here to declare who is or is not a believer. I am simply observing what Scripture tells us to observe, which is the tone, posture, and fruit that come from a person’s life. And when someone who claims Christ begins promoting suspicion and accusation without verified evidence, and when they shift the focus onto themselves during someone else’s grief, Christians must pay attention.

I cannot ignore what I am seeing. I cannot ignore the contrast between the spirit I hear from Erika Kirk and the spirit I hear in commentary defending theories that have no grounding in fact. Erika speaks with humility and sincerity. She speaks with real and raw pain. Her words sound like someone trusting God while navigating the darkest moment of her life. Anyone who has walked through grief knows that sound.

Hearing Allie Beth Stuckey as a Sister in Christ

I also cannot ignore what I see in Allie Beth Stuckey. I have been on her show. I know her character. I know her faith. She is not perfect, and neither am I, but she is a woman of God who speaks with integrity and discernment. Even when she disagrees with someone, she speaks with clarity rather than confusion and humility rather than pride. So when I watch her express concern about this situation and call Christians away from reckless speculation, it resonates deeply with what Scripture teaches. It also echoes concerns I have raised in my blog on False Teachings in Today’s Church, where I discuss the danger of following voices that misrepresent biblical truth.

In contrast, the rhetoric coming from Candace feels unstable and reactionary. It feels driven by suspicion rather than discernment. Again, I am not attacking her heart. I am not judging her soul. I am evaluating the fruit, because Jesus commands believers to evaluate fruit. I am seeing accusations disconnected from verified evidence. I am seeing a pattern of inserting herself into situations that are not about her. I am seeing tones Scripture warns us to avoid.

When Influence Outruns Discernment

I have wondered privately if money or fame may be contributing to this shift. I am not accusing Candace of loving money. I am not claiming corruption. I am pointing out a biblical truth. Scripture repeatedly warns that money can cloud a believer’s vision. Influence can distort motivations. The larger the platform, the greater the pressure to be provocative or reaction driven. Christians with large platforms must fight harder to stay rooted in Scripture. They must invite accountability. They must test every word before speaking.

The spiritual danger is not just about Candace. It is about the entire Christian conservative movement. Too many believers today are being shaped by personalities instead of Scripture. We cannot claim to love truth when we spread claims without evidence. We cannot claim to love our neighbor while harming a grieving widow. We cannot claim to reflect Christ while speaking with anger, pride, or suspicion. There is a difference between boldness and recklessness. One is of the Spirit. One is not.

The Spiritual Lessons from Erika Kirk

This moment with Erika Kirk is a wake up call for believers. We must return to discernment rooted in Scripture rather than emotion. We must reclaim the discipline of waiting for evidence. We must recover the humility of admitting what we do not know. We must protect the innocent through our silence when silence is wise. Grief is holy ground, and we do not get to trample it for content. I said something similar in Frank Turek’s Response to Candace Owens’ Claims, and the warning applies here even more strongly.

Christians are being tested right now. Will we care more about truth than entertainment. Will we protect a widow more than a personality. Will we choose Scripture over speculation. Will we prioritize the fruit of the Spirit over the outrage of the moment. These questions reveal the spiritual condition of our hearts.

What the Church Must Learn Right Now

This blog is not about taking sides. It is not about declaring winners and losers. It is about calling believers back to compassion and truth. It is about honoring a grieving wife who has been forced into a public arena she never desired. It is about rejecting the temptation to elevate influencers above Scripture. It is about remembering that the Body of Christ must reflect Christ, especially when the world is watching.

My prayer is that Candace Owens will pause and consider the fruit of her words. I am not her judge. I am her brother in Christ, and brothers speak truth when love requires it. I pray the Spirit will guide her into humility and clarity. I pray she recognizes the weight of her influence. Influence is not neutral. It builds up or tears down. My hope is that her influence will once again build up.

My prayer for Erika Kirk is comfort, peace, and protection. I pray God surrounds her with believers who guard her heart rather than exploit her pain. I pray the world honors her grief. I pray the Lord silences every false word spoken against her and restores her joy in time.

Most of all, I pray the Church learns from this moment. We cannot allow conspiracy culture to replace Christian culture. We cannot allow reckless speech to replace biblical discernment. We cannot allow pride to replace humility. We cannot allow confusion to replace clarity. God is not the author of confusion, and where confusion reigns, something spiritual is off.

Believers are called to shine light, not heat. We can be bold without being reckless. We can be honest without being harmful. We can be discerning without being suspicious. We can follow Christ without joining the cultural noise. This moment is our reminder.

Arch Kennedy
Bold, Unfiltered, and Unafraid

Watch my full commentary below: